MiFID II Transaction Cost Analysis: New EU Broker Rules

How the 2024 MiFID II review reshaped transaction cost analysis for EU retail brokers, from deleted RTS reports to new execution-quality RTS.

2026-11-14 · Updated 2026-11-15 · 9 min read

Key takeaways

  • The 2024 review deleted Article 27(6) MiFID II, ending the public RTS 28 "top five venues" reports and the venue-side RTS 27 reports.
  • Client cost disclosures still flow from Article 24(4) MiFID II and Delegated Regulation (EU) 2017/565, not from a new retail TCA statement.
  • Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) 2026/825 requires quantitative execution-quality monitoring and an annual policy assessment from 12 February 2028.
  • Article 39a MiFIR bans payment for order flow for retail clients; the last member-state derogation ended on 30 June 2026.

Transaction cost analysis (TCA) measures what an order actually cost once it was executed: the spread paid, slippage against a chosen benchmark price, explicit commission, venue fees, clearing and settlement charges, plus any levy or tax tied to the trade. In the EU it has a legal anchor. Under Article 27 of MiFID II, best execution for retail clients is judged on "total consideration" — the price of the instrument plus all costs directly related to execution, including venue, clearing, settlement and other third-party fees (ESMA single rulebook, Article 27).

That single sentence is why TCA matters to compliance officers: the job is not to advertise the lowest commission, but to evidence the best total outcome.

What the 2024 review changed

The 2024 amending package was published in the Official Journal on 8 March 2024 and entered into force on 28 March 2024. It consists of two acts:

  • Directive (EU) 2024/790, amending Directive 2014/65/EU on markets in financial instruments. Member states had until 29 September 2025 to transpose it (Directive (EU) 2024/790).
  • Regulation (EU) 2024/791, amending Regulation (EU) No 600/2014, which applies directly in all member states (Regulation (EU) 2024/791).

On terminology: the directive is sometimes labelled "MiFID III" in market commentary, but that is not its official title, and neither act is formally titled "MiFIR II". The two texts carry the names above, and the package is generally described as the MiFID II / MiFIR review (ESMA).

Three Level 1 changes matter for execution quality:

  • Article 27(6) MiFID II was deleted. That was the obligation to publish annually the five venues where a firm executed the most client orders, plus information on execution quality — the legal basis for the RTS 28 reports. Recital 8 of the amending directive explains the deletion on the grounds that those reports were hardly read and did not allow meaningful comparisons (Recital 8, Directive (EU) 2024/790).
  • Article 27(3) was replaced with a narrower duty: where an order is executed in an instrument subject to the trading obligations in Articles 23 and 28 MiFIR, the firm must tell the client where the order was executed (amending text).
  • A new mandate let ESMA draft regulatory technical standards on order execution policies, which became Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) 2026/825.

The point that matters for readers: no new standardised TCA document was created for retail clients. The review added to what firms must do internally and removed part of what they had to publish. Client-facing cost and execution information continues to flow from Article 24(4) MiFID II and Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) 2017/565.

ESMA softened the transition. It told national supervisors not to prioritise action on the annual RTS 28 publication pending transposition (ESMA public statement, 13 February 2024), having already done the same for venue-side RTS 27 reports after 28 February 2023 (ESMA public statement, 14 December 2022).

Old regime versus new regime

Dimension Before the 2024 review After the 2024 review
Venue execution-quality data RTS 27 (Delegated Regulation (EU) 2017/575), periodic venue reports Repealed; replaced by internal monitoring against comparison datasets
Firm-level reporting RTS 28 (Delegated Regulation (EU) 2017/576): annual top-five venues plus quality data Repealed; policy effectiveness evidenced to the supervisor and assessed annually
Client-facing execution information Order execution policy summary; Article 24(4) costs and charges disclosure Unchanged in substance
Order-routing incentives Inducements framework under Article 24(9) MiFID II; PFOF permitted in some member states Article 39a MiFIR bans PFOF for retail and opted-up professional clients

The disclosure that already binds EU brokers

What a retail client receives today comes from the cost-and-charges regime: Article 24(4) MiFID II and Article 50 with Annex II of Delegated Regulation (EU) 2017/565. A firm must give an aggregated figure for total costs and charges, then break it down into one-off entry and exit charges, ongoing charges, transaction costs and incidental costs such as performance fees — and disclose payments received from third parties. Pre-contract figures are illustrations, so the actual number can differ. For advisory and portfolio management services, MiFID II additionally requires periodic reporting, which is where an annual statement of costs actually incurred appears (Delegated Regulation (EU) 2017/565).

For a broker, the practical consequence is that an ETF's headline fee is one line in that breakdown. Ongoing product costs, dealing costs and currency conversion on a foreign-listed line all move the total — the same arithmetic covered in our pieces on TER versus total cost of ownership and bid-ask spread and market depth.

The new execution-quality framework

Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) 2026/825 was adopted on 14 April 2026, published in the Official Journal on 23 July 2026, entered into force on 12 August 2026 and applies from 12 February 2028 — about 18 months for firms to adjust policies, procedures and IT. Article 10 repeals RTS 27 (Delegated Regulation (EU) 2017/575) and RTS 28 (Delegated Regulation (EU) 2017/576) (Delegated Regulation (EU) 2026/825). ESMA's final draft was delivered in April 2025 (ESMA final report).

Its architecture is what turns TCA into a legal obligation rather than a good habit:

  • Policy content. Firms must document the governance for selecting venues and keep an internal register listing each venue, when it was approved and by whom, the instrument classes it may serve and whether it is reserved for retail or professional clients.
  • Selection and routing. Venue choice must weigh order type availability, typical client order size and frequency, execution prices against reference data, and the costs charged to the firm. Routing criteria and their relative importance must be documented, and automatic routing systems described.
  • Monitoring against thresholds. Firms must monitor whether orders follow the policy and whether quality is consistent, using pre-set thresholds for indicators such as the accepted deviation of the client execution price from a reference price, and the minimum share of executed client orders meeting those reference prices.
  • Reference data. Monitoring must draw on reference data including, where available, a consolidated tape provider.
  • Annual assessment. Policy effectiveness must be assessed at least annually, and whenever monitoring reveals non-compliance or a material change.
  • Instrument classes. Monitoring must use a fixed list of nine instrument classes plus a residual tenth, with sub-classes where a class does not support effective assessment (Delegated Regulation (EU) 2026/825).

Single-venue brokers face extra scrutiny: a firm using only one venue for a class of instruments must explain in its policy how that venue delivers the best possible result. Where a firm deals on own account against client orders — the typical retail CFD and FX structure — the policy must set out the additional safeguards.

The payment for order flow ban

Article 39a MiFIR prohibits an investment firm acting for retail clients, or for professional clients who have opted up from retail treatment, from receiving any fee, commission or non-monetary benefit from a third party for executing orders on a particular venue, or for forwarding client orders to a third party for execution there (Article 39a, ESMA single rulebook). The prohibition became directly applicable on 28 March 2024, when the amending regulation entered into force (Regulation (EU) 2024/791), subject to a narrow carve-out: rebates or discounts on a venue's approved and public fee schedule that exclusively benefit the client and give no monetary benefit to the firm.

A member state where such payments existed before 28 March 2024 could exempt firms under its jurisdiction until 30 June 2026, provided it notified ESMA by 29 September 2024 (Article 39a(2)). ESMA's published list of member states using that exemption names one country: Germany, which notified on 21 March 2024 (ESMA list of member states). That transitional window closed on 30 June 2026, so from 1 July 2026 the prohibition applies across the EU without exception; BaFin followed with a supervisory statement on 22 July 2026 setting out how it assesses business models, including payments it treats as circumvention (BaFin).

The commercial consequence is direct: an EU broker can no longer fund "zero commission" retail pricing from order-routing revenue. Costs may reappear as explicit commissions, wider spreads or higher platform fees, or be absorbed elsewhere in the business model. Our explainer on payment for order flow sets out the mechanics, and the surrounding reporting duties are covered in retail transaction reporting and algorithmic trading under MiFID II.

How a broker builds the numbers

An execution-quality measurement stack has three layers. The first is the microscopic view of a single order: the quoted spread at arrival, the price actually obtained, and the difference between them, expressed either in basis points or in cash. The second is execution against a benchmark — arrival price, VWAP or a consolidated tape reference — which is the comparison the new standards point firms towards. The third is the summary view: fill rates, rejection rates, the share of orders executed passively versus aggressively, average order size and the mix of venues used.

The reason the visible fee and the true cost can point in opposite directions is that a commission is only one input. A broker charging an explicit per-order fee may source a better price than a nominally free competitor whose fills sit further from the midpoint; the regulatory test is total consideration, not commission. Cross-border orders add a layer that sits outside execution quality but inside the client's real cost, as covered in our piece on currency conversion fees and hedging.

Risks and costs

  • Less public comparability. With RTS 27 and RTS 28 repealed, the free standardised venue and broker reports investors used to download are gone. Firms must still hold the data and demonstrate it to their national competent authority, but third-party comparability increasingly depends on consolidated tape data and firms' own disclosures.
  • Self-set thresholds. The monitoring thresholds are set by the firm itself, so a loose threshold produces a clean report. Supervisory review, not the number alone, is the control.
  • Benchmark sensitivity. Measuring execution against arrival price, VWAP or a consolidated reference can tell three different stories about the same trades.
  • Scope limits. TCA covers execution. Custody fees, platform charges, currency conversion, withholding tax and stock-borrow costs sit outside it, so a good execution score is not a full cost picture.
  • Transformation risk for "free" trading. The Article 39a ban removes an EU revenue stream for retail flow; users of previously commission-free EU brokers should expect pricing structures, spreads or services to change, and should re-read the cost disclosure documents rather than assume the old cost base holds.
  • Timing risk. The new standards apply from 12 February 2028, so firms are operating under their pre-existing policies and procedures until then.
  • Jurisdiction. Everything above applies to firms authorised in the EU. In other jurisdictions the frameworks, disclosures and remedies for retail clients are not interchangeable. Nothing here is a recommendation to buy, sell or hold any security or to use any broker.

Bottom line

For EU retail brokers, the 2024 MiFID II review swapped a public reporting exercise for an internal, data-driven one: delete RTS 27 and RTS 28, ban payment for order flow for retail flow, and from 12 February 2028 require quantitative execution-quality monitoring against reference data with a documented annual assessment behind it. For retail investors the practical change is subtler. The mandatory cost information you receive still comes from the pre-existing cost-and-charges and order execution policy disclosures, while the free public comparison tables have disappeared — which makes reading your broker's own cost breakdown, and asking for its execution policy when conflicts appear, a more useful habit than it was before.

This article is for information and education only. It is not investment advice and does not take into account your personal situation. Read the full disclaimer.

Follow the shortlist

Focused on execution, costs and risk management? Our global ETF and stock research watchlist is tracked daily. Premium members get the full list, the reasoning behind every entry and updates when entries change.

See premium access

Information and education only, not investment advice.

Related