SEC Market Structure Reforms: What Retail Traders Need to Know
A US proposal would drop hard price protection for displayed quotes, while new execution-quality reports put broker routing and fill quality under a brighter spotlight.
Key takeaways
- In the US, the SEC's June 2026 proposal would rescind Rule 611, the trade-through rule, and the ban on locked and crossed quotes, replacing a hard price-protection floor with broker best-execution duties
- Amended Rule 605 has widened monthly execution-quality reporting since 1 August 2026 and added a summary report that lets traders compare brokers on a like-for-like basis
- Spread cost depends on more than the quoted price: tick size, access fee caps and venue routing all feed into the effective spread you actually pay
- Nothing is final, because the Rule 611 rescission is only a proposal and EU rules under MiFID II work differently, so a cost model built on one compliance date is fragile
Two rulebooks, one question: where does your order go?
For a US retail trader, execution looks simple: an order, a fill price, a confirmation. Behind it sits a chain of decisions — which venue receives the order, at what fee, against which displayed quote, and under what obligation to seek the best available price. The SEC is pulling on two ends of that chain at once: an order-protection rule that is two decades old, and an execution-disclosure regime that was rewritten this year.
This article covers what has changed, what is only proposed, and how each piece feeds into spread costs, venue selection and routing transparency. Everything below concerns US rules for NMS stocks — exchange-listed US equities and exchange-traded funds. The EU's equivalent framework runs through MiFID II and is not interchangeable (see our MiFID II reporting guide).
The Order Protection Rule is on the table
What Rule 611 does today
Rule 611 of Regulation NMS — the Order Protection Rule, or trade-through rule — took effect with Regulation NMS in 2005 (SEC, Regulation NMS final rule, Release No. 34-51808). It requires trading centres, including exchanges, alternative trading systems and brokers executing internally, to maintain policies that prevent trade-throughs of protected quotations: a customer buy should not execute above the best displayed offer, and a sell should not execute below the best displayed bid. Rule 610(e) complements it by prohibiting quotations that lock or cross another venue's displayed price.
What the Commission has proposed
On 11 June 2026 the SEC proposed to rescind Rule 611 and Rule 610(e) entirely, along with related defined terms in Rule 600 and conforming changes elsewhere in Regulation NMS (SEC, Trade-Through Rule and Locked and Crossed Markets Provisions, File No. S7-2026-20; SEC press release 2026-54). Comments closed on 17 August 2026 (same docket).
The Commission's stated case is that a highly automated, interconnected market no longer needs a hard price-protection floor, and that broker-dealer best-execution duties can act as the safeguard (Commissioner Uyeda's statement on the proposal, 11 June 2026). The SEC's Division of Trading and Markets has explicitly asked commenters how execution quality and best execution would evolve without the rule.
The economics, and the pushback
The proposing release puts aggregate annual system-maintenance savings at $22.8 million to $45.6 million, against roughly $40.9 million in one-time implementation costs (SEC proposing release, Release No. 34-105655). The same release values the compliance relief at about $250,000 per trading day (SEC proposing release, Release No. 34-105655).
Citadel Securities, in a comment letter filed on 17 August 2026, called the daily saving trivial relative to a US equity market that trades more than $1 trillion of notional on an average day, and warned that the change would let brokers bypass better displayed exchange prices more easily, pushing more retail order flow off-exchange (Citadel Securities comment letter, File No. S7-2026-20). The firm's preferred alternative is a minimum trading-volume threshold for protected-quote status.
A volume threshold as a fallback
That idea appears in the proposal as well. On trading activity from September 2025 to February 2026, restricting protected-quote status to venues with at least a 1% share of average dollar volume would leave seven exchanges covered, while a 2% cut-off would leave six (SEC proposing release, Release No. 34-105655). None of this is final: Rule 611 remains in force unless and until the Commission adopts an amendment.
Execution-quality disclosure has already changed
Amended Rule 605, adopted on 6 March 2024, is the transparency half of the package, and unlike the Rule 611 proposal it is live (SEC, Disclosure of Order Execution Information). It widened the set of firms required to publish monthly execution-quality reports to include broker-dealers with larger numbers of customer accounts, alternative trading systems and single-dealer platforms — not only market centres — and added a summary report alongside the detailed statistics, with fractional-share, odd-lot and larger-order categories.
The original compliance date of 14 December 2025 was extended to 1 August 2026 (SEC final rule, Release No. 34-104147). Reporting entities had to publish the first monthly reports, covering August 2026, before the end of September 2026 (FINRA Information Notice, 17 June 2026).
Tick sizes and access fees: the spread-sensitive third piece
In the US, spread economics also depend on rules the SEC adopted on 18 September 2024. The access fee cap for protected quotations was cut to $0.001 per share for NMS stocks priced at $1.00 or more, and to 0.1% of the quotation price for stocks under $1.00, replacing the previous ceiling of $0.003 per share (SEC press release 2024-137).
The same package added a second minimum quotation increment. Stocks priced at $1.00 or more with a Time Weighted Average Quoted Spread of $0.015 or less over an evaluation period may be quoted in $0.005 increments; others keep the $0.01 tick (17 CFR 242.612; SEC small entity compliance guide on tick sizes). Ticks are assigned stock by stock and recalculated twice a year: an evaluation from January to March applies from the first business day of May through October, and July to September governs November through April (SEC small entity compliance guide on tick sizes). The Commission noted that many NMS stocks would likely be priced more competitively without the market-wide one-cent minimum (SEC press release 2024-137).
These pieces are explicitly connected: on the same day it proposed to rescind Rule 611, the Commission issued a statement revisiting the minimum pricing increments and access fee caps (SEC statement, 11 June 2026).
What this means for spread costs
- Quoted versus effective spread. A tighter tick can narrow the displayed spread, but what you pay is the effective spread — the difference between the midpoint and your fill. A narrower quote paired with worse routing can leave you paying more.
- Internalisation economics. Most US retail marketable orders are filled by wholesalers rather than on exchanges, a model tied to payment for order flow. Without a trade-through floor, the incentive to route or internalise away from the public quote grows — which can be cheaper or dearer depending on the price improvement on offer.
- Total cost, not tick size. Access fees and rebates, and the market depth available at each venue, all feed into realised cost. A sub-penny improvement on a retail order can outweigh a full tick on a thin book.
What this means for venue selection
For a broker in the US, venue choice becomes a documentation exercise: without a hard prohibition, the firm must be able to show why a venue was reasonable for that order, not merely that the venue displayed the best price. The working assumption among market participants is that the national best bid and offer will remain the yardstick for that review, which pushes the burden onto the paper trail. For a trader, the practical reading is that a protected quote should be treated as a floor that may weaken, not a constant.
What this means for order-routing transparency
- Read the new Rule 605 reports. The summary report is designed for comparison between brokers on the same order categories — the like-for-like view that was previously hard to assemble.
- Use Rule 606 to see incentives. Rule 606 requires brokers to disclose order-routing practices, which is where conflicts of interest show up.
- Know the enforcement standard. For US brokers, best execution is enforced through FINRA Rule 5310, a supervisory obligation backed by examination rather than by a single rule on routing.
| Element | Now (US) | If the Rule 611 rescission is adopted |
|---|---|---|
| Better displayed price | Protected by Rule 611 | Protection removed; broker must justify routing afterwards |
| Locked and crossed quotes | Prohibited by Rule 610(e) | Permitted; may appear in market data |
| Execution-quality data | Amended Rule 605, live since 1 August 2026 | Unchanged |
| Routing disclosure | Rule 606 disclosures | Unchanged |
| Access fee cap | $0.001 per share at or above $1.00; 0.1% below $1.00 | Rationale to be revisited alongside Rule 611 |
Risks and costs
- Protection gap. If Rule 611 is rescinded, individual orders could fill at prices worse than the best displayed quote. The counterweight, best execution, is enforced through supervision and documentation rather than a hard prohibition.
- Hidden-cost risk. Cheaper venue routing can appear as a tight spread while shifting cost into fee capture, fill quality or internalisation. A tighter tick does not automatically lower total cost of ownership.
- Fragmentation risk. A less reliable market-wide benchmark makes off-exchange activity harder to interpret and execution quality harder to police.
- Timing and legal risk. The Rule 611 rescission is a proposal, not a rule. Compliance dates in this rule family have already moved once: Rule 605 slipped from 14 December 2025 to 1 August 2026 (SEC final rule, Release No. 34-104147). A cost model built on a single date is fragile.
- Jurisdiction. These are US rules for NMS stocks. In the EU, execution and disclosure duties flow from MiFID II, and the two regimes are not interchangeable.
Bottom line
The direction of travel in the US is a lighter price-protection floor paired with heavier execution-quality and routing disclosure. Practically, more of your protection now comes from what a broker publishes and can defend than from a single guaranteed quote. Read the amended Rule 605 summary reports, use Rule 606 to see routing incentives, and treat venue and spread comparisons as quality questions rather than tick-size arithmetic. The Rule 611 rescission stays on our research watchlist; nothing changes until it is adopted.
Follow the shortlist
Tracking how market structure changes affect investors? Our global ETF and stock research watchlist is tracked daily. Premium members get the full list, the reasoning behind every entry and updates when entries change.
See premium accessInformation and education only, not investment advice.
Related
T+1 Corporate Actions: Dividends, Rights and Spin-Offs
How next-day settlement moved the ex-date onto the record date in the US, what that means for dividends, rights issues and spin-offs, and the deadlines investors must reset.
MarketsWhat Is a CCP? Clearing, Risk Waterfalls and Retail Trades
A central counterparty stands behind most modern trades. Here is how CCP clearing works, what the default waterfall does in a crisis, and what it means for retail investors and traders.
MarketsCorporate Actions Explained: Dividends, Mergers and Spin-Offs
How dividends, splits, rights issues, mergers, spin-offs and tender offers work — ex-dates, record dates, broker cut-offs, position and tax effects, and the cost of doing nothing.