Securities Lending in ETFs: Revenue Splits and What Can Go Wrong
How ETF issuers lend fund holdings, who keeps the income under the two most common models, how collateral and disclosure work in the EU and the US, and where the risks sit.
Key takeaways
- Splits run from 62.5% of gross income at BlackRock's UCITS range to about 97% of gross net of costs at Vanguard, so the basis of the split matters as much as its size
- Lending typically adds only a few basis points to returns, which is why the on-loan percentage matters as much as the split
- In the EU, funds must be able to enforce collateral at any time, and collateral reaching 30% of assets must be stress-tested, while SFTR pushes revenue and cost breakdowns into the periodic reports
- The risks that cost money are counterparty default, cash-collateral reinvestment, recall liquidity and agent conflicts, not the fee split itself
Securities lending, in one paragraph
The fund owns the shares or bonds. A broker-dealer, bank or hedge fund needs those same securities for a short sale, a hedge or settlement, and borrows them temporarily in exchange for a fee and collateral. While a position is out on loan the fund keeps the dividends and the market exposure, so the lending programme is meant to change nothing economically apart from adding income Vanguard explains the mechanics.
The loan is a two-way contract. The borrower pledges collateral — cash or high-quality securities — and pays a fee that reflects how hard the security is to borrow, how long the loan runs and market conditions. Loans are usually short, from days to weeks, and the fund must be able to call the securities back.
For the plumbing that connects borrowing and recalls to fund creation and redemption, see our earlier piece How ETF Securities Lending Works: Revenue, Risks, Disclosure. This article is about the money: who keeps it, where it is disclosed, and what the documents do not say out loud.
The two numbers that decide your share
Almost every issuer describes its lending economics as a percentage of revenue. The problem is that revenue can be measured two ways.
Gross revenue is everything the borrowers paid before programme costs. Net revenue is what is left after the agent lender has taken its costs — transaction and operational expenses, and sometimes cash-collateral management fees. The share the fund keeps is calculated on one basis or the other, and issuers choose different ones. That single drafting choice can move the fund's take by tens of percentage points, which is why comparing two factsheet claims in isolation is close to meaningless.
Model 1: a fixed split of gross income
In BlackRock's UCITS iShares range, funds participating in securities lending retain 62.5% of the income, while BlackRock receives 37.5% and covers all the operational costs arising from the transactions. The wording sits on the issuer's fund pages, for example on the iShares S&P 500 Information Technology Sector UCITS ETF page. Because the agent absorbs the costs, the 62.5% is a share of gross revenue, not of a smaller net number.
Model 2: all revenue minus programme expenses
Vanguard's US-domiciled funds work differently. The firm says it returns all lending revenue, net of the expenses it incurs running the programme, to the funds: programme expenses run around 3% of gross revenue, so roughly 97% flows back to shareholders, and it notes that some asset managers keep upward of 19% of gross revenue as a fee split Vanguard's securities lending Q&A. Its investor page puts the revenue returned to funds at 95.2% for 2024 Vanguard.
Those two documented examples span roughly 62.5% to 97% of gross income for the fund. They are cited as disclosure examples from issuer documents, not as recommendations or watchlist items.
Why the headline percentage is still not the answer
A higher split is not automatically better for the investor. A fund quoted as receiving "100% of net revenue" may carry agent costs that never appear as a percentage, while an explicitly lower gross split can come with an indemnity and full cost absorption by the agent. And in most structures the lending agent is an affiliate of the manager, so the split and the cost allocation are negotiated inside the same corporate group — a related-party arrangement that is worth checking before you treat the percentage as a competitive signal.
How much is actually on loan
The other half of the equation is volume. Across the market, EquiLend's 2024 review put lendable supply at about $27.9 trillion and balances on loan at around $1.8 trillion, with average fees of just under 30 basis points, a decline of about 20% on the year EquiLend, The Purple, Q1 2025. That average hides enormous dispersion: a hard-to-borrow small cap can command a fee many times a large-cap index constituent.
At fund level, the on-loan share is reported per period. On the iShares S&P 500 Information Technology Sector UCITS ETF product page, average on-loan balances across the reported annual periods through 30 September 2026 range from 0.51% to 4.64% of assets, with a maximum on-loan figure of 10.54% in the earliest reported period. Vanguard describes its own portfolios as having on average about 1% or less out on loan over the five years to 2023, and says it lends only equities, not bonds Vanguard Q&A.
Read those two facts together and the practical rule becomes obvious: a 97% split of revenue on 0.5% of the portfolio is a rounding error, while a lower split applied to 5% of a scarce holding can matter.
What lending is worth in return terms
Vanguard's own measurement is that securities lending income added roughly 1 to 5 basis points to annual returns for its US equity index funds and ETFs, depending on the market-cap category, and 1 to 9 basis points across the broader industry, over fiscal years from January 2019 through December 2022 The value of securities lending in three charts. The same analysis found lending offset between 23% and 90% of expense ratios on average — a striking percentage, but one that reflects very low fee levels rather than large lending profits.
The iShares technology fund page illustrates the other end of the range. For every annual period reported through 30 September 2026, its disclosed securities lending return is shown as 0.00% iShares product page. The figure is displayed to two decimal places, which is why a low-demand, large-cap portfolio can carry lending balances and still show no measurable return. Treat any lending claim in basis points as an average over a period, not a promise for the next one.
Collateral does most of the work
Collateral is what stands between the fund and a borrower that fails. Vanguard requires cash collateral equal to 102% to 105% of the market value of the borrowed securities, adjusted daily Vanguard Q&A; the iShares UCITS fund page reports collateralisation of between about 110% and 112% of loan value across the periods it discloses iShares.
In the EU, the rules reach further than overcollateralisation percentages. Under ESMA's guidelines on ETFs and other UCITS issues, all collateral must satisfy criteria on liquidity, valuation, issuer credit quality, correlation, diversification and enforceability; the fund must be able to enforce the collateral at any time without the counterparty's approval; non-cash collateral may not be sold, reinvested or pledged; and cash collateral may only be placed with prescribed institutions or invested in specified low-risk instruments CFA Institute summary of the guidelines. The same framework requires a fund that receives collateral worth at least 30% of its assets to maintain a stress-testing policy, testing collateral liquidity under normal and exceptional conditions ESMA Guidelines on liquidity stress testing in UCITS and AIFs, restating paragraph 45 of the ETF guidelines. Recallability is part of the same package: a UCITS must be able to recall securities it has lent or terminate the arrangement ESMA Guidelines on ETFs and other UCITS issues.
Where the numbers are disclosed
The lending economics are almost never in the marketing factsheet. They are in the statutory documents.
| Where to look | UCITS (EU) | US-registered fund |
|---|---|---|
| Prospectus / SAI | Maximum and expected share of assets that may be lent, collateral policy, revenue-sharing policy, whether fee recipients are related parties | Lending policies, collateral terms, risk disclosures |
| Half-yearly / annual report | SFTR disclosure: on-loan share, top counterparties and collateral issuers, and the fees and revenue split between fund, manager and third parties | Financial statements: gross lending income, agent fees, net income to the fund |
| Regulatory filing | SFTR transaction reporting to trade repositories | Form N-CEN: lending agent identity, affiliation and indemnity arrangements |
The UCITS column is statutory, not best practice. SFTR requires managers of EU funds to inform investors about their use of securities financing transactions in the half-yearly and annual reports SFTR, Regulation (EU) 2015/2365. In the US, the equivalent visibility comes from the annual financial statements and from Form N-CEN, which asks whether the fund uses a lending agent, whether that agent is affiliated with the adviser and whether it indemnifies the fund against borrower default SEC Form N-CEN.
Risks and costs
- Counterparty default. A borrower can fail while securities are out. Collateral plus an agent indemnity normally covers the gap, but an indemnity is only as strong as the balance sheet behind it, and the fund absorbs any shortfall if collateral proves insufficient.
- Cash-collateral reinvestment. Historically the larger loss driver was not default but what was done with reinvested cash collateral; some lenders took losses on reinvested cash collateral during the global financial crisis, and Vanguard says it reinvests its own cash collateral only in an internal money market fund Vanguard Q&A. EU rules now constrain the destinations, but the risk is managed rather than removed.
- Recall and liquidity. Funds are obliged to be able to recall loans, yet recalls can be slow in stressed markets and the market can move before a position is restored. The wider question of ETF behaviour under stress is covered in Corporate Bond ETF Liquidity: Spreads, Premiums and Stress Risk.
- Agent conflicts and disclosure quality. The agent lender is frequently the manager's affiliate, which shapes how the split and cost allocation are set. The EU's reporting requirements exist partly because investors otherwise cannot see those economics.
- Cost visibility. Lending revenue and its associated fees sit outside the ongoing charge, so TER comparisons — covered in TER vs Total Cost of Ownership: What an ETF Really Costs — do not capture them in either direction.
- Tax treatment. In several jurisdictions the treatment of lending-related income differs from that of dividends, so check local rules before assuming the income is tax-neutral for your situation.
In the EU and in the US: label the differences
In the EU, a UCITS must return lending revenue to the fund net of direct and indirect operational costs, disclose the arrangement in its documents, and report the SFTR table of on-loan positions, counterparties and revenue splits in its half-yearly and annual reports. In the US, no rule prescribes a revenue split: the constraint is disclosure plus operational requirements such as being able to recall loans within the ordinary settlement period, with the split negotiated between the manager and the agent. Funds outside the UCITS framework — including Swiss-domiciled products and some US ETFs traded in Europe — are not covered by the ESMA guidelines at all CFA Institute. Jurisdiction determines what you can see, not how much you earn.
Bottom line
Securities lending in ETFs is a marginal revenue line with real operational mechanics behind it. The split matters, but only after you know how much of the portfolio is on loan, how the collateral is structured, who the agent is and whether that agent is related to the manager. In the EU you get a standardised, legally required breakdown of those economics in the half-yearly and annual reports; in the US you get annual financial statements and Form N-CEN entries. Read those before you read a factsheet claim about enhanced returns.
Follow the shortlist
Comparing ETFs on cost, liquidity and structure? Our global ETF and stock research watchlist is tracked daily. Premium members get the full list, the reasoning behind every entry and updates when entries change.
See premium accessInformation and education only, not investment advice.
Related
Single-Stock ETFs: Leveraged and Inverse Funds Under the Microscope
How single-name leveraged and inverse ETFs work, why daily resetting compounds badly on one volatile stock, and what they really cost to hold.
ETFsETF Liquidity Metrics: Amihud Ratio, Spreads and Creation Flow
Measure ETF liquidity in three steps: quote the bid-ask spread, compute the Amihud illiquidity ratio, then read creation and redemption flow to forecast your trading cost.
ETFsBuffer ETFs: How Defined-Outcome Funds Cap Gains and Limit Losses
Defined-outcome buffer ETFs use FLEX options to absorb part of an index decline while capping upside, but the stated outcome only holds if you buy at the start of the period and hold to the end.