Stablecoin Regulation Compared: EU MiCA vs the US GENIUS Act

How MiCA and the GENIUS Act differ on who may issue payment stablecoins, what must back them, how redemption works and where depeg risk still sits.

2026-11-19 · 10 min read

Key takeaways

  • Both regimes converge on 1:1 reserves, licensed issuers, prompt redemption at par and a ban on paying yield to holders
  • The EU regulates token categories and can cap payment use of non-euro tokens, while the US regulates issuers and splits federal from state supervision above $10bn
  • Segregated reserves and bankruptcy protection reduce loss-given-default but do not stop secondary-market depegs, as the March 2023 USDC episode showed
  • Dollar tokens sold into the EU sit under two rulebooks at once, so licence status, reserve composition and redemption policy need to be read before, not after, holding them

Two rulebooks for the same instrument

Payment stablecoins are now covered by two detailed regimes. In the EU, the Markets in Crypto-Assets Regulation applies its rules for e-money tokens and asset-referenced tokens from 30 June 2024 (Regulation (EU) 2023/1114). In the US, the Guiding and Establishing National Innovation for U.S. Stablecoins (GENIUS) Act became law on 18 July 2025 (Public Law 119-27).

Both texts answer the same three questions: who may issue, what must sit behind the token, and on what terms holders can get out. They differ in structure: the EU regulates categories of tokens and their issuers, while the US regulates the issuer and divides supervision between federal and state authorities.

Scale matters for reading the rules. Aggregate stablecoin market capitalisation reached about $317bn as of 6 April 2026, according to a Federal Reserve research note (FEDS Note, April 2026). Most of that supply is dollar-denominated, which is why the EU's treatment of non-euro tokens is followed closely on both sides of the Atlantic.

If you want the reserve-composition detail on its own, our earlier explainer on EU and US reserve rules covers it instrument by instrument.

Who may issue a payment stablecoin

In the EU: two token categories, two licensing routes

MiCA splits fiat-referenced tokens into two products:

  • E-money token (EMT) — references one official currency and must be redeemable at par, at any time, by the issuer. Only a credit institution or an e-money institution authorised under EU e-money rules may issue one.
  • Asset-referenced token (ART) — references anything else, including baskets or commodities. Issuers need authorisation from a national competent authority and must hold own funds equal to the highest of €350,000, 2% of the reserve of assets, or a quarter of fixed overheads, rising to 3% of the reserve for significant tokens (MiCA text).

A token is "significant" when at least three of seven criteria are met, including more than 10 million holders, more than €5bn in value issued or reserves, or more than 2.5 million transactions and €500m a day (ESMA single rulebook, Article 43; EBA/Commission criteria). Significant status brings the European Banking Authority into supervision alongside national regulators, plus stricter liquidity and audit duties.

Separately, MiCA caps everyday use of non-euro EMTs as a means of exchange: above an average of 1 million transactions and €200m a day within one currency area, the issuer must stop issuing and submit a remediation plan within 40 working days (MiCA text). Euro-denominated tokens are not subject to that cap.

Firms that custody or exchange tokens for customers need crypto-asset service provider authorisation; the EU's transitional window for such providers ended on 1 July 2026 (ESMA, MiCA).

In the US: permitted issuers, federal or state

The GENIUS Act requires issuers to be approved "permitted payment stablecoin issuers", either federally or under a state regime that is substantially similar to the federal framework (Congressional Research Service overview). Key structural points:

  • Issuers with consolidated outstanding issuance of no more than $10bn may opt into state-level regulation. Above $10bn, a state-qualified issuer must transition to the federal framework within 360 days or stop issuing new tokens (12 U.S.C. §5903).
  • Issuers with more than $50bn outstanding must publish audited annual financial statements (CRS).
  • Permitted activities are narrow: issuing, redeeming, managing reserves, custody and directly related support work (Act text).
  • Issuers are exempt from the regulatory capital standards applied to banks, but face tailored capital, liquidity, diversification and risk-management rules set by their regulators (CRS).

The Act's provisions take effect on the earlier of 18 months after enactment or 120 days after the primary federal regulators issue final implementing rules (Public Law 119-27). The OCC's final rule was published on 23 October 2026 (Federal Register).

What has to sit behind the token

Feature EU (MiCA) US (GENIUS Act)
Issuer Credit institution or e-money institution (EMT); authorised ART issuer Permitted issuer approved federally or by a state regime (state option up to $10bn)
Reserve standard 1:1, segregated from the issuer's estate; at least 30% of funds in separate accounts at credit institutions, 60% for significant EMTs, the rest in secure low-risk assets At least 1:1 in identifiable reserves: cash and coins, Fed balances, insured bank deposits, short-dated Treasury bills, Treasury-backed repos, government money market funds, central bank reserves
Interest to holders Prohibited Prohibited
Redemption At par, at any time (EMT); per published policy (ART) Publicly disclosed redemption policy and timely redemption
Escalation Significant tokens get EBA/ESMA involvement and stricter duties; payment-use cap on non-euro EMTs Federal transition above $10bn; audited financials above $50bn; reserves excluded from the issuer's bankruptcy estate

Reserve assets are the core protection in both texts, and both restrict what qualifies: the GENIUS Act lists permitted reserve categories in the statute itself (12 U.S.C. §5903), while MiCA sets a percentage floor of funds held at credit institutions for EMTs and detailed custody, segregation and valuation duties for ART reserves (MiCA text).

Neither regime makes a holder a depositor. Tokens are not covered by deposit insurance in the US or by deposit guarantee schemes in the EU; the protection is the segregated reserve, not a state backstop (Act text; MiCA text).

In the EU, an EMT must be redeemable at par at any time, so the legal right is unconditional in form. What varies is the operational route: minimum redemption sizes, cut-off times and KYC checks on large redemptions sit in the issuer's published terms, and the token's payment function depends on banking rails that still close overnight and at weekends.

In the US, the Act requires a publicly disclosed redemption policy with clear procedures for timely redemption (12 U.S.C. §5903). The OCC's final implementing rule set out how the redemption clock starts and stops — redemption is treated as occurring when the issuer initiates the outgoing transfer or credits the customer's account — and dropped a proposed automatic seven-day extension that would have applied when redemption requests exceeded 10% of outstanding issuance in a 24-hour period, on the basis that such an extension could itself be pro-cyclical (Federal Register, 23 October 2026).

The practical lesson is that a par claim against the issuer and a token trading at par on an exchange are different things. Secondary-market prices move before, and often against, the primary market's ability to process requests.

Interest, yield and the economics of reserves

Both rulebooks ban paying holders interest or yield purely for holding the token: in the US the prohibition is explicit in the statute (12 U.S.C. §5903), and MiCA likewise bars EMT issuers from granting interest (MiCA text). The OCC's final rule also declined to adopt a proposed rebuttable presumption aimed at "indirect yield" arrangements, leaving the boundary to case-by-case supervision (Federal Register).

That shapes issuer economics. Revenue comes from income on the reserve portfolio — Treasury bills and government money market funds — net of distribution fees paid to exchanges and wallets, custody and audit costs, and compliance overhead. Holders effectively give up that yield in exchange for liquidity and settlement utility, whether they want that trade or not. Costs to watch are the on/off-ramp fee, the spread between the market price and par, and network fees on the transfer rail.

Depegging and issuer failure: what the rules can and cannot prevent

The best-documented stress case in a reserve-backed dollar token is USDC in March 2023. Circle disclosed that it could not withdraw $3.3bn of reserves — around 8% of the roughly $40bn then backing the token — held at Silicon Valley Bank, and the secondary-market price fell to $0.87 before recovering once redemptions resumed (Federal Reserve FEDS Note).

Two structural points follow. First, risk sat in the reserve's banking counterparty, not in the token's design. Second, because stablecoins trade continuously on secondary markets, suspending primary-market redemptions cannot halt a run the way closing a bank can — a point the Federal Reserve makes explicitly in its work on primary and secondary stablecoin markets. First movers get par; later movers get whatever the secondary market offers.

On issuer failure, the US Congress amended the bankruptcy code so that required payment stablecoin reserves are excluded from the issuer's estate, with the automatic stay still applying to them (Public Law 119-27). MiCA mirrors this logic through segregation: token funds and reserves must be kept apart from the issuer's own assets. Segregation improves recovery in a wind-down, but it does not guarantee speed of recovery, and it does not create a guarantee fund or a lender of last resort for token holders.

What it means for banks, payment firms and users

Banks

Both regimes allow banks to be issuers: in the EU a credit institution can issue an EMT under its existing authorisation, and in the US insured depository institutions can become permitted issuers. The competitive question is deposit funding. A dollar token backed by Treasury bills is a substitute for a non-interest-bearing deposit account, and central banks have flagged the disintermediation channel as a financial-stability consideration in their own research (FEDS Note, April 2026). Banks that issue gain fee and float revenue but take on reserve, redemption and operational duties that look more like a fund administrator's than a lender's.

Payment firms

In the EU, offering custody or exchange of tokens is a crypto-asset service requiring authorisation, with the transitional period over. In the US, the GENIUS Act addresses issuers; intermediaries still face state money transmission licensing and federal anti-money-laundering obligations. Operationally, both environments require reconciliation between 24/7 token settlement and banking-hour settlement, plus clear rules on who bears the loss if a token fails to convert in time — the settlement-risk question addressed in our explainer on payment rails.

Businesses and users

Redemption rights, reserve disclosure and the absence of yield apply to holders regardless of size, so the practical checklist is: who is the licensed issuer, what exactly is in the reserve, what does the redemption policy say about timing and fees, and which jurisdiction's rules apply to you. In the EU, the non-euro payment cap can also affect which dollar tokens remain usable at scale for euro-area payments; in the US, state-by-state licensing still shapes who can touch the token downstream.

Risks and costs

  • Depeg risk. Secondary-market prices can fall below par even when the reserve is intact, because runs interact with leverage, market-maker inventory and exchange halts. Losses fall on sellers, not on the issuer.
  • Reserve counterparty and duration risk. Bank deposits carry bank failure risk; Treasury bills carry duration and rollover risk in fast rate moves. Segregation protects against the issuer's own creditors, not against losses in the assets themselves.
  • Run dynamics. Redemption is first-come, first-served. The rules do not remove the incentive to exit early.
  • Costs. Reserve management, custody, audit, attestation and distribution fees, plus user-facing spreads, on/off-ramp fees and transfer fees.
  • Regulatory divergence. A dollar token distributed in the EU faces MiCA and, for its issuer, US rules at the same time; compliance analysis is jurisdiction-specific and cannot be generalised.
  • Custody and key risk. Holding through a custodial wallet transfers operational and insolvency risk to the intermediary; self-custody transfers key-management risk to the holder.
  • No deposit protection. Neither regime extends deposit insurance or a guarantee scheme to token holders.
  • Tax and accounting. Treatment differs by jurisdiction and by holder type — in the EU it is largely national tax law, in the US federal rules on payments and disposals apply to US persons. Take specialist advice rather than extrapolating from another country's guidance.

For adjacent topics, see our notes on tokenised money market funds and CBDC retail design choices.

Bottom line

MiCA and the GENIUS Act have converged on the same core bargain: full reserve backing, a licensed issuer, redemption at par on published terms, and no yield paid to holders. The differences are structural rather than philosophical. The EU regulates token categories, sets a 30%-to-60% floor on bank-held funds for e-money tokens, involves the EBA and ESMA once a token becomes significant, and can cap payment use of non-euro tokens. The US regulates issuers, splits federal and state supervision at the $10bn line, requires audited financials above $50bn and makes reserves bankruptcy-remote. Neither design eliminates depeg risk: the March 2023 USDC episode showed that a well-reserved token can trade 13% below par on counterparty news. Anyone holding or accepting these instruments for payments should read the licence, the reserve composition and the redemption policy before relying on the peg.

This article is for information and education only. It is not investment advice and does not take into account your personal situation. Read the full disclaimer.

Follow the shortlist

Following payments, banking and market-infrastructure change? Our global ETF and stock research watchlist is tracked daily. Premium members get the full list, the reasoning behind every entry and updates when entries change.

See premium access

Information and education only, not investment advice.

Related