Exchange Fees and Rebates: Maker-Taker and Inverted Venues

Maker-taker rebates, inverted venues and tiered fee schedules decide where orders are routed and what a trade really costs. Here is how the models work, and how to measure them.

2026-11-11 · 9 min read

Key takeaways

  • Exchange fees are quoted per share, so $0.0030 means 0.30 cents, or $3.00 on 1,000 shares
  • Maker-taker venues pay for resting orders and charge for crossing the spread; inverted venues reverse the sign
  • Rebates usually accrue to the broker, and pass-through depends on gross versus net pricing
  • Judge a venue on effective spread, realized spread and price improvement, not on the fee sheet alone

Why exchange fees belong on your cost sheet

Exchanges publish transaction fees as per-share rates carried to four decimal places. A rate of $0.0030 means 0.30 cents per share, or $3.00 on a 1,000-share order; $0.00020 means $0.20 on the same order. Because the charge scales with shares rather than notional value, the same schedule costs relatively more on a $12 stock than on a $400 one. That matters most to high-turnover strategies trading liquid, low-priced instruments.

Fees also steer your order before it is filled. When two venues display the same price, a broker may earn more by sending the order to one of them. That does not make the routing improper, but it does mean the schedule is part of your execution outcome, not only your broker's cost line. For the spread and depth half of the same cost stack, see Bid-Ask Spread and Market Depth; for the retail brokerage side of routing revenue, see Payment for Order Flow.

Two pricing models, one arithmetic

Maker-taker: the venue pays for resting orders

In a maker-taker market, the venue pays a rebate to the member whose resting order is executed and charges the member who crosses the spread. The SEC's own description of the model uses a $0.003 charge to remove liquidity against a $0.002 rebate to add it, leaving the venue a tenth of a cent per share (SEC, maker-taker fees on equities exchanges). Real schedules follow the same shape at a larger scale: Cboe's November 2024 update listed a $0.0027 rebate for adding and a $0.0030 charge for removing liquidity in EDGA Tape B names (Cboe equities fee schedule update).

Two consequences follow. The rebate is funded out of the take fee, so a venue cannot lift rebates indefinitely while its access fee is capped. And adding liquidity only pays if the position survives long enough: passive orders accept adverse selection risk in exchange for the credit.

Inverted venues: the sign flips

An inverted, or taker-maker, venue charges for resting liquidity and rebates the member who removes it. The SEC memo notes that a small number of venues have adopted this structure (same memo). Cboe's current standard rate for BYX is $0.00200 to add liquidity and a $0.00020 rebate to remove it, for securities priced at or above $1.00 (Cboe BYX fee schedule).

For flow that almost always crosses the spread — a momentum entry, a stop-driven exit, a rebalance — the difference is easy to compute. On 1,000 shares, taking liquidity on a $0.0030 schedule costs $3.00; taking it on the BYX schedule pays $0.20. That is a $3.20 gap per leg, or roughly $160 on 50,000 aggressive shares a day, before any difference in fill price.

The trade-off is not free. Venues that charge for posting tend to attract a different mix of flow, and displayed depth can be thinner precisely because showing a quote costs money. A cheaper take fee on a book that fills you last on a fast move is a poor bargain.

Comparing published rates

Venue example Pricing model Add liquidity Remove liquidity Source
Cboe EDGA, Nov 2024 schedule (Tape B) maker-taker $0.0027 rebate $0.0030 fee Cboe
Cboe BYX, standard rate, $1.00 and above inverted $0.00200 fee $0.00020 rebate Cboe
NYSE Arca, lead market maker tier, ETPs under 1m CADV tiered maker-taker $0.0045 credit $0.0029 fee NYSE Arca

The original schedules use parentheses for rebates; the table spells out "fee" and "rebate" so the sign is unambiguous. All three are per-share rates for the specified tier, not a general price list. Several of these schedules predate the lower access fee caps adopted in 2024 (see below); venues revise rates often, so always read the live schedule before comparing costs.

Tiers, thresholds and routing codes

Standard rates are rarely the best rates on a sheet. Nasdaq's price list ties the higher add rates to a member's share of consolidated volume, so the credit a desk receives depends on how much it adds market-wide (Nasdaq trading price list). NYSE Arca's schedule tiers credits by the average daily volume of the products concerned (NYSE Arca fees and charges). The practical result: the same execution can cost one firm several times what it costs another.

Two further lines matter on any schedule. Routed executions are billed at the destination venue's rate plus a routing fee of their own, which makes "smart routing" an explicit cost decision rather than a free service. And odd lots, closing auctions and non-displayed orders are usually priced separately from the displayed round-lot book.

Who actually keeps the rebate

Pass-through is a commercial choice, and it splits brokers into two camps. Under gross pricing the client pays a disclosed commission or spread and the broker keeps venue economics; under net pricing the venue credits flow back into the client's execution. Whether a retail account sees any per-share rebate at all is therefore a matter of the broker's pricing model, not of the exchange's schedule.

Regulators have drawn a line here. In the EU, Article 39a(1) of MiFIR permits venue rebates and discounts only where they sit inside the venue's approved and public tariff structure and exclusively benefit the client, and states that they must not produce a monetary benefit for the investment firm (ESMA, Article 39a). That single sentence separates a client rebate from broker revenue.

The rules that bound the schedule

In the US

Rule 610(c) of Regulation NMS caps the fee a trading centre may charge for executing against a protected quotation: historically $0.0030 per share for stocks at or above $1.00, and 0.3% of the quotation price below $1.00 (SEC final rule on minimum pricing increments and access fee caps). The SEC adopted amendments in 2024 that reduce those caps to $0.001 per share and 0.1% respectively, alongside changes to tick sizes and the round-lot definition (SEC press release, 2024). The SEC has since issued exemptive orders affecting when firms must comply with parts of these amendments (SEC exemptive order, 2025), so check the current status before relying on either cap.

Note the asymmetry that survives any cap. A cap limits what a venue charges takers; it says nothing about what a venue pays makers. That is why inverted venues, where the access fee is negative, are not constrained by the cap at all.

Rule 605 requires market centres, and after the 2024 amendments brokers with a larger number of customer accounts, to publish monthly execution-quality statistics (SEC press release, March 2024). Required measures include average effective spread, the ratio of effective to quoted spread, realized spread at 15 seconds and one minute, and price improvement measured against the best available displayed price (17 CFR 242.605). Rule 606 sits alongside it, requiring customer-specific routing disclosures on request (17 CFR 242.606).

In the EU

The EU runs no per-share access fee cap. It relies instead on best-execution duties, venue transparency and a prohibition on receiving payment for order flow. Article 39a of MiFIR bars investment firms acting for retail clients, and for professional clients that opt in, from receiving third-party payment for routing orders to a venue. The ban became applicable in March 2024, with a temporary exemption for member states where affected firms were established before 28 March 2024, running until 30 June 2026 (ESMA, MiFIR Article 39a).

As published, ESMA's list under that exemption names Germany only, which notified on 21 March 2024 (ESMA exemption list). German supervisors have since confirmed that the ban applies in full from 1 July 2026, with supervisory expectations set out through 30 June 2029 (BaFin supervisory statement on the PFOF ban). The underlying framework comes from the 2024 MiFIR review (Regulation (EU) 2024/791).

Conflicts and routing incentives

Fee structures create incentives that are legal, disclosed and still worth understanding:

  • Rebate capture. A broker or desk choosing between venues quoting the same price has a financial interest in one of them. Customer-specific disclosure rules in the US and the PFOF ban in the EU exist precisely because that interest is real.
  • Internalisation. In the US, wholesalers pay for retail flow and typically return part of it as price improvement inside the national best bid and offer. The mechanics differ from venue rebates; the tension between routing revenue and fill quality does not.
  • Threshold chasing. A desk close to a volume tier has an incentive to trade more than it otherwise would, which can add turnover costs to reach a better rebate. Tier structures deserve scrutiny for that reason alone.
  • Concentration. When a large share of retail flow is internalised rather than shown, the displayed book is thinner for everyone else. This is a market-quality argument, not a cost argument, and it is debated rather than settled.

Measuring execution quality

Two orders arriving at the same quote can end with different prices, and the fee sheet will not tell you which venue did better. Four measures do most of the work:

  • Effective spread: twice the absolute difference between the execution price and the midpoint when the order was received. It captures spread plus all improvement and disimprovement.
  • Quoted spread and the effective-to-quoted ratio. Rule 605 now requires a spread-weighted version of this ratio, which prevents a venue from flattering its number by shifting improvement between wide and narrow names.
  • Realized spread at 15 seconds and one minute, also required under the amended rule. A high realized spread suggests the liquidity provider kept most of the spread after the market moved; a low or negative figure points to adverse selection.
  • Price improvement measured against the best available displayed price, including odd lots — a stricter benchmark than the NBBO alone, which is why the amended rule moved to it.

In practice, work through four steps. Pull the venue's Rule 605 report and your broker's; compare like-for-like order types and size buckets, because averages across all sizes hide the segment you trade. Log the quote at order arrival yourself, or ask your broker for the data, so you can compute your own effective spread rather than rely on an aggregate. Reconcile the per-share fees on your statement against the schedule tier you were told you were on. Finally, if you test a routing change, do it on a slice of flow and hold it long enough to see fills in different volatility regimes.

Risks and costs

  • Optimization can cost more than it saves. A $0.0030 rebate is 0.30 cents. One cent of worse fill on 1,000 shares is $10, roughly 3,000 shares worth of rebate. Fee comparisons that ignore fill quality are arithmetic without a purpose.
  • Adverse selection. Posting to earn credits means carrying inventory through fast moves, where the rebate is trivial against the loss.
  • Inverted venues. The cheaper take can come with thinner books and a worse queue position on the orders you actually need filled.
  • Over-trading to reach tiers, which raises commission, spread and tax costs to chase a per-share cent.
  • Cost stack beyond transaction fees: market-data and connectivity charges are published on the same pages as the transaction schedules and are recurring, not per trade (Cboe BYX schedule).
  • Disclosure lag. Rule 605 reports are monthly and backward-looking; venue-level averages can still mask the sub-segments and order types you use.
  • Jurisdiction. The US retains payment-for-order-flow-based retail models, while EU retail flow is now largely routed without such payments, which changes broker economics and product menus. Nothing in this area applies universally, and the applicable rules depend on where you and your broker are established.

Bottom line

Exchange fee schedules are a two-column problem: what the venue charges you to take, and what it pays you or your broker to post. Read the tier you actually qualify for, not the headline rate, and establish who captures the rebate before assuming it reaches your account. Then judge the result with effective spread, realized spread and price improvement data, because the visible fee is the smallest part of the cost of a trade and the price you got is the largest.

This is information and education only, not a recommendation of any venue, price level or strategy.

This article is for information and education only. It is not investment advice and does not take into account your personal situation. Read the full disclaimer.

Follow the shortlist

Focused on execution, costs and risk management? Our global ETF and stock research watchlist is tracked daily. Premium members get the full list, the reasoning behind every entry and updates when entries change.

See premium access

Information and education only, not investment advice.

Related