Short Selling Rules in the EU and US: Locates, Disclosure and Bans
A practical guide to how short selling is regulated in the EU and the US: borrow and locate requirements, net short position disclosure thresholds, close-out deadlines and temporary bans.
Key takeaways
- Short selling requires borrowing or locating shares first, and that requirement is enforced differently in the EU and the US
- EU transparency works through a two-tier net short position regime, while the US relies on broker-level locates, a price test and hard close-out deadlines
- Temporary restrictions are triggered by significant single-day price falls or by wider exceptional circumstances, and are always jurisdiction-specific
- The core economics of a short position are borrow fees, dividend-equivalent payments, recall and buy-in risk, and a theoretically unlimited loss
How short selling actually works
A short sale is the sale of a security the seller does not own, with the intention of buying it back later to close the position. To deliver the shares on settlement, the seller has to borrow them — usually from a broker's inventory, an institutional lender or another client's account. The borrower pays a fee, normally quoted as an annualised rate on the value of the borrowed shares.
Two requirements separate a regulated short sale from a bare bet. Shares must be available to borrow, or at least located; and a large position must be disclosed and settled on time. The EU and the US enforce both principles, but through very different rulebooks, and the differences matter to anyone trading across both.
The locate requirement
In the US, Rule 203(b)(1) of Regulation SHO requires a broker-dealer to have reasonable grounds to believe the security can be borrowed before accepting a short sale order. That is the "locate". Exceptions exist for bona fide market-making activity, but a retail short sale normally needs a locate first — which is why a platform may simply refuse the order in a hard-to-borrow name.
In the EU the requirement is statutory rather than a broker-level condition. Article 12 of the Short Selling Regulation, Regulation (EU) No 236/2012, prohibits uncovered short sales of shares and sovereign debt. Before selling short, a person must have borrowed the shares, entered into an agreement to borrow them, or have an arrangement with a third party who has confirmed the shares are located. The compliance burden sits with the participant, not with an exchange price rule.
EU rules: the Short Selling Regulation
Administered by ESMA together with national competent authorities (NCAs) — Germany's BaFin, France's AMF or the Netherlands' AFM, for example — the EU regime rests on three pillars: the ban on uncovered short sales, a transparency regime for net short positions, and intervention powers for supervisors.
Disclosure thresholds
Disclosure is built around the net short position: short exposures netted against long holdings and certain derivatives, calculated at group level.
- Notification to the relevant NCA is required once a position reaches 0.1% of issued share capital, and again at each 0.1% above that (Article 5(2), as amended).
- Public disclosure is required at 0.5% and each 0.1% above that (Article 6(2)).
Both tiers sit in the SSR text on EUR-Lex. The regulation originally set the notification tier at 0.2%; following ESMA's opinion on the notification threshold, a Commission delegated regulation lowered it permanently to 0.1% with effect from 31 January 2022, as ESMA's statement on the new threshold explains. A compliance process should still treat the consolidated regulation text and the relevant NCA register as the source of truth.
Sovereign debt is handled separately: ESMA publishes the applicable notification thresholds for each sovereign issuer, and holders notify their NCA when a position reaches or crosses those levels.
The regime is not static. On 16 March 2020, during the first wave of COVID-19 market stress, ESMA used its Article 28 intervention power to lower the notification threshold for shares admitted to regulated markets temporarily to 0.1%, recorded in ESMA Decision (EU) 2020/525; that temporary level later became the permanent one. The numbers in force can change quickly in a stressed market.
When regulators step in
Article 23 of the SSR requires an NCA to consider restricting short selling when the price of a financial instrument has fallen significantly during a single trading day — 10% or more in the case of a liquid share. A measure taken under Article 23 applies for no longer than the end of the trading day following the fall, and can be extended by up to two more trading days if the decline continues; NCAs may exempt market-making and primary-market activity.
Wider powers sit in Articles 20 and 28 of the SSR: an NCA can impose restrictions in exceptional circumstances, and ESMA can intervene directly where a measure has cross-border implications. Individual NCAs have used those powers during periods of market stress to impose temporary bans on particular shares in their markets.
The UK runs a separate regime
After Brexit the UK onshored the EU SSR as assimilated law under the European Union (Withdrawal) Act 2018 and now operates its own framework overseen by the FCA. Under the FCA's short selling framework, positions in UK reportable shares are notified to the FCA at 0.2% of issued share capital and each 0.1% above that, and the FCA publishes aggregate net short positions rather than identifying individual holders. A group trading both EU and UK shares can therefore face two reporting streams, with different thresholds, different portals and different deadline conventions.
US rules: Regulation SHO
US short selling rules sit in Regulation SHO under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934. Four rules do most of the work.
Marking, locates and the price test
- Rule 200 requires every sell order to be marked long, short or short exempt, so the receiving broker knows what it is handling.
- Rule 203(b)(1) is the locate requirement described above.
- Rule 201, the alternative uptick rule, is a circuit breaker: if a stock falls by at least 10% from the prior day's closing price, short sales in that security may only be executed at a price above the current national best bid for the rest of that day and the following day.
Close-outs and threshold securities
Delivery failures are policed by Rule 204. A clearing participant must close out a fail to deliver arising from a short sale by the beginning of regular trading hours on the settlement day following the settlement date; fails arising from a long sale, or attributable to bona fide market-making, get until the third consecutive settlement day after the settlement date. Under the former T+3 cycle those deadlines landed on T+4 and T+6. Since the US moved to a T+1 settlement cycle on 28 May 2024, the same counting rule lands earlier in calendar days — see our explainer on T+1 settlement. Failing to close out carries a pre-borrow penalty: the firm, and any broker-dealer clearing through it, cannot take further short sale orders in that security without first borrowing the shares.
A subset of hard cases becomes a threshold security. Under Rule 203(b)(3), a security qualifies as a threshold security when its aggregate fail to deliver position is at least 10,000 shares and at least 0.5% of shares outstanding for five consecutive settlement days; fails in a threshold security that persist for 13 consecutive settlement days must then be closed out immediately by purchasing shares of like kind and quantity, as the SEC explains in its Regulation SHO guidance and trading and markets FAQ. Threshold lists are published daily by the exchanges and are a useful public indicator of names that are becoming expensive or impossible to short.
How a short position is financed is covered in our guide to margin calls and maintenance requirements, and where lendable supply comes from in our explainer on how ETF securities lending works.
Temporary bans: how they are triggered
| Feature | EU (SSR) | US (Reg SHO) |
|---|---|---|
| Price-fall trigger | NCA must consider restricting short selling after a single-day fall of 10% or more in a liquid share (Article 23) | Rule 201 price test applies after a 10% fall from the prior close |
| Typical duration | Until the end of the following trading day, extendable by up to two more trading days | Remainder of that day plus the following trading day |
| Wider powers | Articles 20 (NCA, exceptional circumstances) and 28 (ESMA intervention) | SEC action by emergency order |
| Exemptions | Market-making and primary-market activity | Bona fide market-making, certain short-exempt orders |
Bans are the part of short selling rules most likely to surprise an active trader, because they can appear with little notice and apply only to specific instruments or trading venues. A position that is compliant at entry can become restricted overnight.
Risks and costs
Short selling is asymmetric. A long position can only fall to zero; a short position has a theoretically unlimited loss, because the price has no ceiling. Everything below is a recurring, real cost, not a footnote.
- Borrow fees. The stock borrow rate is charged on the value of the position and varies enormously with supply and demand. It is set by the broker or lender and can rise sharply when a name becomes crowded or appears on a threshold list.
- Dividends and corporate actions. If the borrowed shares pay a dividend, the short seller owes a payment in lieu. A rights issue, merger or conversion can force an unexpected cash outflow.
- Recall risk. Lenders can call back borrowed shares at short notice. If no replacement borrow can be found, the position may be bought in at whatever price the market offers.
- Buy-in and close-out risk. Failure to deliver triggers mechanical buy-ins under both the EU settlement regime and US Rule 204, and those purchases can lock in losses at an unfavourable price.
- Regulatory risk. Disclosure thresholds, price tests and temporary bans can change the rules mid-position. In the EU, tax and reporting treatment of borrow fees, dividend-equivalent payments and short sales in annual filings is jurisdiction-specific and not universal — take local advice.
This material is information and education only. It is not investment advice, and nothing here is a recommendation to buy, sell or hold any security.
Bottom line
Both regimes rest on the same logic: you must be able to source the shares, disclose a large position, and settle on time or be forced to close. The EU leans on net short position transparency, with a notification tier at 0.1% (lowered from 0.2% in 2022) and a public disclosure tier at 0.5%, both moving in 0.1% steps, plus an Article 23 trigger at a 10% single-day fall in a liquid share. The US leans on broker-level locates under Rule 203(b)(1), a 10% price-test circuit breaker under Rule 201, and close-out deadlines under Rule 204 that now arrive sooner under the T+1 cycle. Bans are the wild card in both jurisdictions: instrument-specific, jurisdiction-specific, and capable of appearing within a single trading day. Treat borrow fees, recall risk and buy-in risk as the core economics of the trade, and keep in mind that venue threshold lists and active NCA or regulator restrictions can change the picture at any time.
Follow the shortlist
Focused on execution, costs and risk management? Our global ETF and stock research watchlist is tracked daily. Premium members get the full list, the reasoning behind every entry and updates when entries change.
See premium accessInformation and education only, not investment advice.
Related
0DTE Options Explained: Same-Day Expiry Volume and Risk
What zero-days-to-expiry contracts are, why they now dominate S&P 500 index options activity, and the gamma, execution and settlement risks retail traders take on.
TradingOptions Assignment and Exercise Risk for Retail Traders
How US-listed equity options are exercised and assigned at expiry — pin risk, dividend-related early assignment, broker margin policy, and where EU retail access differs.
TradingRetail Margin Trading: Leverage, Costs and Regulatory Safeguards
How retail margin trading works: Regulation T and FINRA requirements, the real price of borrowed money, liquidation triggers, and the safeguards US and EU rules provide.